RCSAs | Data Visualization | Design Thinking | Audit Newsletters | Tools | Musical Productivity

Risk management isn’t just about compliance—it’s about making smarter decisions before audit steps in.

This week, we’re diving into how organizations can level up their governance game with well-executed Risk and Control Self-Assessments (RCSAs), leveraging data visualization to make audit insights clear and actionable, and applying design thinking to drive real business improvements. We’ll also explore how a concise executive audit newsletter can keep leadership informed without overwhelming them.

Whether it’s turning risk assessments into proactive tools, refining audit reporting, or making governance more effective, the goal remains the same: stop checking boxes and start driving real value.

As a reminder—

• AuditPal Spotlight: Highlights of internal audit trends.
• Back of the Napkin: One new thing I learned this week.
• Borrowing Inspiration: Ideas or tools from other fields.
• Auditcraft: Update on what I tried or failed at this week.
• Tools of the Trade: A roundup of interesting ideas I found.
• foo: Random thoughts or ideas not necessarily related to audit.

Now that you’re up to speed, read on! 🙂

---

Zac Explains Audits is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

---

AuditPal Spotlight:

What is a Risk and Control Self-Assessment?

Risk and Control Self-Assessments (RCSAs) are like the coal mine canary allowing an organization to evaluate their own risks and controls before external or internal audit are knocking. The goal is to identify key risks, assess the strength of existing controls, and document gaps. In theory, this should be a game-changer for proactive risk management, but you must be careful because they can often turn into a check-the-box exercise with little real value. The focus should be on providing value to the company, not just saying something is right or wrong. Materiality and risk levels always matter in these types of engagements.

Why RCSAs Matter More Than You Think

Auditors love RCSAs because they shift risk awareness from “someone else’s problem” to an active, front-line responsibility. Rather than waiting for an external audit to uncover risks, management teams have a chance to get ahead of issues before they escalate.

A well-executed RCSA empowers teams to:

• Detect and address risks in real-time
• Improve internal controls before gaps become audit findings
• Strengthen accountability across departments
• Reduce regulatory and financial exposure

Done right, an RCSA makes risk management a proactive function.

The Pitfalls of a Poorly Executed RCSA

Many RCSAs are done because someone at some point heard the buzzword and decided they needed them. However, this kind of approach can cause many of the most common issues that ultimately render them ineffective:

1. The Rubber-Stamp Problem – If teams aren’t candid about risks, they’ll downplay issues to avoid scrutiny. This defeats the entire purpose of the exercise.
2. Lack of Clear Criteria – If there’s no structured approach to assessing risks and controls, responses become subjective, inconsistent, and unreliable.
3. Too Much Focus on Compliance – Some companies treat RCSAs as a regulatory requirement rather than a valuable risk management tool. As a result, they prioritize looking good over being good.
4. Limited Data-Driven Insights – Without data to validate risks and control effectiveness, assessments are based on opinions rather than facts.
5. No Follow-Through – Identifying risks without addressing them is like diagnosing an illness and refusing treatment. If there’s no action plan, what’s the point?

How to Make RCSAs Actually Work

If your company is going to invest time in an RCSA, it should deliver real results.

1. Use a Structured Framework

A good RCSA isn’t a free-for-all survey. Use a structured methodology specifying phases like:

• Risk Identification: Define key risks specific to your industry and operations.
• Control Evaluation: Assess existing controls based on effectiveness, not just existence.
• Gap Analysis: Identify weaknesses and prioritize corrective actions.

Leveraging frameworks like COSO, COBIT5, or ISO 31000 can provide consistency and credibility to the assessment.

2. Be Open About Risks

Encourage teams to be candid and do not punish them for finding issues. Create an environment where employees feel safe discussing risks without fear of repercussions. If everyone says, “No issues here!” you’ve got a problem. Consider anonymous feedback mechanisms to get a more honest picture.

3. Use Data to Validate Responses

Subjective opinions on control effectiveness won’t cut it. Support assessments with:

• Incident reports
• Control test results
• Internal audit findings
• External benchmarking

Data-driven RCSAs lead to more accurate risk identification and stronger justifications for improvements.

4. Tie RCSAs to Real Action Plans

RCSAs should be more than a report that sits in a folder until next year. Establish clear action plans with:

• Assigned owners for risk mitigation efforts
• Timelines for control enhancements
• Metrics to track progress

Follow-up reviews should ensure risks don’t just get identified—they get addressed.

5. Make It a Continuous Process

Risk doesn’t operate on an annual schedule, and neither should RCSAs. High-risk areas should be assessed more frequently, and RCSAs should integrate with ongoing risk monitoring efforts.

The Bottom Line

A well-run RCSA is one of the most valuable risk management tools a company can have. It shifts risk identification from a reactive function to a proactive strategy, ensuring that potential issues are caught before they spiral. But for that to happen, organizations need to ditch the checkbox mentality and commit to structured, data-driven, and action-oriented assessments.

---

Back of the Napkin:

The Power of Data Visualization in Audit Reporting

If you want executives to tune out, throw a 30-page audit report at them. If you want them to act, show them the data—visually.

Executives are busy. They don’t have time to comb through dense paragraphs and tables of audit findings. And let’s be honest—most of them won’t. But give them a well-placed heatmap, trendline, or risk dashboard, and suddenly, the message clicks.

The Power of Visual Storytelling

Numbers tell a story, but only if presented in a way that people can grasp quickly. Visuals bridge the gap between raw data and actionable insight. Studies show that the brain processes images 60,000 times faster than text, and 90% of the information transmitted to the brain is visual (Link).

For auditors, this means leveraging tools like Power BI, Tableau, or even Excel charts to turn complex data into intuitive charts that drive decisions.

What Works

1. Heatmaps: Great for showing risk concentration. A heatmap that highlights high-risk areas in red and lower-risk areas in green allows executives to grasp risk exposure in seconds.
2. Trendlines: Essential for showing movement over time. Want to demonstrate how an internal control issue has worsened over the last three years? A trendline will make the point clearer than a paragraph of explanation.
3. Dashboards: A well-designed dashboard can turn multiple data points into an at-a-glance summary of audit findings, risk ratings, and areas requiring urgent attention.

The “Data Puke” Effect

Here’s where many auditors go wrong: they think more charts equal more clarity. Instead, they create an overwhelming flood of visuals that confuse rather than clarify.

Too many graphs, complex visualizations, or poorly labelled charts can have the same effect as a dense wall of text—executives will tune out. The goal isn’t just to make data pretty; it’s to make it meaningful.

How to Keep It Simple (and Effective)

• Focus on key messages. Every visual should serve a purpose. Ask yourself: “What decision does this help drive?”
• Use intuitive visuals. If you must explain a chart for more than 10 seconds, it’s probably too complicated.
• Limit the number of visuals per slide or page. One strong, well-labelled chart beats five competing for attention.
• Choose the right type of visual. Avoid pie charts for complex comparisons. Use bar charts for ranking, line charts for trends, and heatmaps for risk severity.
• Label everything clearly. A confusing or vague axis label can derail an entire presentation.

The Bottom Line

Your audit report is only as valuable as the action it drives. If executives can’t immediately see what’s wrong and what needs to be done, your message is lost.

Next time you’re wrapping up an audit, resist the urge to bury findings in paragraphs and tables. Instead, let visuals do the heavy lifting. Keep them simple, focused, and designed for quick comprehension. Because at the end of the day, an audit report is only as good as the decisions it influences.

---

Borrowing Inspiration:

Using Design Thinking Principles to Enhance Audit Processes

Design thinking—a concept rooted in product development—has helped companies like Apple, Google, and IDEO create user-friendly, innovative solutions. But here’s the twist: it’s not just for designers. Auditors, of all people, can leverage this approach to make engagements more effective, insightful, and (dare we say it?) even enjoyable.

The old-school audit playbook is all about rigid checklists, predefined workpapers, and the thrill of catching control failures. But that method often ignores a crucial element: the people involved. Auditees aren’t just boxes to be checked. They have concerns, frustrations, and operational realities that don’t always fit neatly into a standard audit program.

This is where design thinking changes the game.

The Five Phases of Design Thinking (and How Auditors Can Use Them)

Design thinking isn’t about aesthetics—it’s about solving complex problems through a structured yet flexible approach. It consists of five core stages:

1. Empathize – Understand the user’s (auditee’s) perspective.
2. Define – Frame the real problem to be solved.
3. Ideate – Generate creative solutions.
4. Prototype – Test ideas quickly and iteratively.
5. Test – Implement, refine, and adjust based on feedback.

Let’s break these down in an audit context:

1. Empathize: See the Audit Through the Auditee’s Eyes

Traditional audits start with reviewing policies, running analytics, and diving into past reports. But what if we started by truly understanding the auditee’s experience?

• Conduct pre-audit workshops where teams discuss their biggest challenges.
• Ask open-ended questions: What keeps you up at night? Where do you see inefficiencies?
• Map out the user journey of key processes—not just controls, but how employees experience them.

By stepping into their shoes, auditors shift from being compliance enforcers to problem-solvers. Instead of “gotcha” moments, audits become collaborative efforts to improve processes.

2. Define: Reframe the Audit’s Purpose

Once you’ve gathered insights, the next step is defining the core problems. Too often, audits focus on control failures without considering the root cause.

A design-thinking approach asks: Are we solving the right problem?

For example, if employees frequently bypass a control, the issue might not be noncompliance—it could be that the control is cumbersome, inefficient, or redundant. Instead of writing a finding, the real value comes from helping fix the underlying process.

Reframing audit objectives to address business pain points rather than just compliance gaps leads to more impactful results.

3. Ideate: Brainstorm Solutions, Not Just Findings

In a typical audit, findings are presented at the end, often as a surprise to management. Design thinking changes this by making problem-solving a shared process.

• Host collaborative brainstorming sessions with auditees to explore fixes together.
• Use “How Might We” statements (e.g., “How might we improve approval workflows without slowing down operations?”).
• Consider alternative approaches beyond traditional control recommendations—maybe automation, process redesign, or even training is the real solution.

Bringing stakeholders into the solution process increases buy-in and leads to better outcomes.

4. Prototype: Test Small, Fail Fast, Improve Quickly

The best way to see if a solution works? Try it before rolling it out organization-wide.

Instead of issuing a formal recommendation and waiting for the next audit cycle, auditors can:

• Pilot process changes in one department before applying them company-wide.
• Run simulations of control improvements to gauge effectiveness.
• Leverage real-time analytics to see if proposed fixes work.

This iterative, hands-on approach prevents audit recommendations from gathering dust and ensures real improvement.

5. Test: Adapt and Evolve Based on Feedback

Most audits end with a report and an action plan. But in a design-thinking framework, the audit’s impact continues after the exit meeting.

• Follow up sooner to see if recommendations are working.
• Adjust solutions based on operational realities rather than sticking to rigid recommendations.
• Treat audit findings as dynamic insights rather than static conclusions.

The result? Audits don’t just check compliance; they drive real change.

Why This Approach Makes Auditors More Valuable

Design thinking isn’t just a trendy concept—it makes auditors indispensable business partners.

• Better Relationships – Auditees see auditors as allies rather than adversaries.
• More Useful Insights – Instead of generic findings, audits lead to meaningful process improvements.
• Greater Organizational Impact – Auditors contribute directly to efficiency, risk reduction, and innovation.

Companies don’t need auditors to just find what’s wrong; they need them to help make things right. Design thinking enables that shift.

Bringing Design Thinking Into Your Next Audit

Want to experiment with design thinking in your audit team? Start small:

✅ Replace your standard kickoff meeting with an empathy workshop.
✅ Reframe findings as opportunities for co-created solutions.
✅ Test recommendations in a small-scale pilot before finalizing them.
✅ Follow up frequently and adjust based on feedback.

Audit doesn’t have to be a rigid, checklist-driven process. By embracing design thinking, auditors can become true catalysts for innovation—solving real problems instead of just documenting them.

Because let’s be honest: a well-designed audit is one that actually makes a difference.

---

Auditcraft:

Launching an executive newsletter

In an age where inboxes are cluttered with reports, alerts, and memos, convincing executives to read an audit newsletter might sound like an uphill battle. But the truth is, a well-crafted audit newsletter can be a great way to keep executives informed more frequently than a quarterly meeting. It can bridge the gap between audit teams and leadership, making complex risks and compliance updates digestible, actionable, and even (dare I say) interesting.

Why Your Company Needs an Executive Audit Newsletter

Executives don’t have time to sift through lengthy audit reports. But they do need to know about:

• Key risks that could impact strategic objectives
• Regulatory updates that require immediate action
• Audit findings that highlight operational inefficiencies
• Emerging trends in governance, risk, and compliance (GRC)

A short, engaging newsletter serves as a high-impact touchpoint, ensuring leadership stays informed without drowning in details.

What Makes an Audit Newsletter Effective?

Let’s be honest—most corporate newsletters are either too dry or too long. The goal here is to create something executives will actually open and read. Here’s how:

1. Keep It Short, Sharp, and Structured

Executives aren’t reading essays. Aim for 400-600 words max, broken into clear sections:

• Headline: A sharp, curiosity-inducing title (e.g., “New SEC Rule Could Shake Up Your 2025 Strategy”)
• Snapshot Section: Three bullet points summarizing the issue in 30 seconds or less
• Main Content: A short analysis of the issue and its business impact
• Actionable Takeaways: What leadership should know or do next

2. Use Simple, Impactful Language

Avoid audit jargon. Instead of writing: “The recent regulatory change necessitates a reevaluation of internal control frameworks,” try: “New SEC rules mean we need to tweak how we handle financial reporting—here’s what that means for us.”

Executives value clarity. If they need to decipher your writing, they won’t read it.

3. Focus on What Matters to Executives

Your audit team might be excited about a new COSO framework update—but will your CFO care? Maybe, if you frame it as: “A simple update to our risk strategy could save us $500K in compliance costs.”

Always tie audit insights to:

• Financial impact
• Operational efficiency
• Regulatory risk
• Strategic objectives

4. Consistency is Key

A sporadic newsletter loses traction. Decide on a frequency—monthly works well—and stick to it. Consider a recurring format, such as:

• “Top 3 Audit Insights This Month”
• “What’s Keeping Regulators Up at Night”
• “The One Risk We Shouldn’t Ignore”

5. Make It Visually Appealing

Dense text is a turnoff. Use:

• Bullet points
• Bold key takeaways
• Graphs or quick data snapshots
• Links for those who want to dive deeper

Getting Buy-In: How to Ensure Engagement

Your newsletter won’t matter if no one reads it. Here’s how to make sure it doesn’t end up in the corporate abyss:

• Get leadership endorsement – If the CEO or CFO mentions the newsletter in a meeting, others will pay attention.
• Deliver it at the right time – Avoid sending it on Monday mornings or Friday afternoons. Mid-week, mid-morning works best.
• Use a compelling subject line – “Audit Updates – Q4” is boring. “New Audit Insight That Could Save $1M” gets clicks.
• Make it scannable – If an exec can get value in 30 seconds, they’ll keep opening it.
• Solicit feedback – Ask leaders what they want to see more (or less) of. Adjust accordingly.

Final Thoughts

An executive audit newsletter isn’t just another report—it’s an opportunity to position audit as a strategic partner in the business. When done right, it transforms audit insights into a must-read asset, fostering stronger decision-making, risk awareness, and compliance engagement across the leadership team.

If your audit team isn’t in the room when key decisions are made, a killer newsletter might just be your ticket in.

---

Tools of the Trade:

• Tool: Power Query – For Excel data extraction & transformation,
• Read: Data Analytics for Internal Auditors – Richard Cascarino – Great book to learn about data analytics specific to internal audit.
• Watch: Edspira – Accounting and auditing explained simply.

---

Foo:

The Intersection of Music and Productivity—How Different Genres Affect Focus

Audit documentation and death metal? Maybe not the best mix.

We all have that one playlist we swear by when trying to power through work. But have you ever stopped to think about why certain types of music help—or hinder—your productivity? Science has a lot to say about how music affects focus, and if you play your cards (or playlists) right, you might just find the perfect sonic fuel for every task on your to-do list.

The Science of Sound and Productivity

Research shows that music impacts the brain in several ways, influencing mood, focus, and efficiency. The key factors at play include:

• Tempo: Faster beats can increase alertness and motivation, while slower rhythms promote relaxation and concentration.
• Lyrics: Songs with words can be distracting during tasks that require reading or complex thinking, as they compete for the brain’s language-processing resources.
• Familiarity: Listening to familiar music can be soothing and help with focus, whereas unfamiliar music might pull attention away.
• Genre and Instrumentation: Different musical styles trigger different cognitive and emotional responses, impacting productivity in unique ways.

Matching Music to Your Task

Not all work is created equal, and the same goes for music. Here’s how to match the right soundtrack to what you’re working on:

1. Deep Focus Work (Analyzing Financials, Writing Reports, Coding)

• Best Genres: Classical, Lo-fi, Ambient, White Noise
• Why It Works: These styles are low on distractions and create a steady, non-intrusive background atmosphere. Classical music, particularly Baroque composers like Bach and Vivaldi, has been linked to improved concentration.
• Pro Tip: Try playlists with 50-70 beats per minute (BPM) for optimal focus.

2. Repetitive or Routine Tasks (Data Entry, Email Sorting, Organizing Files)

• Best Genres: EDM, Pop, Upbeat Instrumentals
• Why It Works: High-energy beats keep your motivation up and prevent mental fatigue from setting in.
• Pro Tip: If you’re dragging through mindless admin work, a well-timed pop anthem can help you pick up the pace.

3. Brainstorming & Creative Work (Risk Assessments, Strategy Development, Presentations)

• Best Genres: Jazz, Indie, Movie Soundtracks
• Why It Works: These genres promote free thinking and creativity. Jazz and indie music provide variety without overwhelming the brain, while movie scores can make even the dullest brainstorming session feel epic.
• Pro Tip: Hans Zimmer might just make your risk analysis feel like a scene from Inception—give it a shot.

4. High-Pressure, Deadline-Driven Work (Audit Crunch Time, Last-Minute Reports)

• Best Genres: Rock, Hip-Hop, Motivational Playlists
• Why It Works: When stress levels rise, music that pumps up adrenaline can help you stay engaged and push through. Rock and hip-hop tracks provide a sense of urgency and confidence.
• Pro Tip: Save the high-energy playlist for when you really need that last burst of focus.

Experiment and Build Your Ultimate Work Playlist

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, and personal preference plays a big role. The best way to optimize your music for productivity? Experiment. Try different genres for different tasks and note what works best for you.

A few questions to consider:

• Do lyrics distract or help you zone in?
• Does tempo affect your ability to concentrate?
• Do you work better with familiar or new music?

If you’re feeling adventurous, mix it up with binaural beats or nature sounds—both have been shown to improve cognitive performance.

The Bottom Line

The right playlist can make even the most tedious tasks slightly more enjoyable. Whether you’re knee-deep in spreadsheets or drafting your next big audit report, soundtracking your work strategically might just be the productivity hack you didn’t know you needed.